This Ain’t No Party Bus: Movement Lessons From the Brandon Johnson Administration

This Ain’t No Party Bus: Movement Lessons From the Brandon Johnson Administration

“Election day he shouted ‘a socialist for mayor’

The comrade got elected, he happy was for fair

But after the election he got an awful shock

A great big socialistic bull did rap him on the block.

And Comrade Block did sob,

‘I helped him to his job.’”

(”Mr. Block” by Joe Hill)

Truck of Thrones

One evening in late March 2023, a church leader and I were standing out in the cold dark, waiting for Brandon Johnson. Suddenly an amazing vehicle appeared: A crusty old delivery truck that had been transformed with color, lights, a magnificent video screen, and a killer sound system. Inside were two magnificently gaudy thrones. Across the front was a website address that began “HOUSEMUSICTRUCKING.

The chariot of Chicago house music legend DJ Farley had become a fixture of the Brandon Johnson campaign. It was part of the advance team that preceded him to events. It was also one of the most Chicago things ever. 

The truck was so fitting, because house music is an essential ingredient of what Brandon Johnson regularly describes as “the soul of Chicago.” For those that don’t know,  house music is an intensely strange and wonderful genre of electronic dance music that was brewed out of Chicago’s empty industrial real estate, marginalized identities, crates of old soul records, innovation, and intense spiritual dedication to fun.

Since Johnson was elected, I have reflected on that vehicle as the symbol of all our hopes and dreams. It seemed like this crusty old delivery truck was transformed into a beacon of joy and hope was a personification of Chicago. It felt like we were putting Brandon in the driver’s seat to carry us into a glorious new future. Brandon said frequently on the campaign trail that he was going to bring the people to “the 5th floor,” and we wanted to get on that party bus with him.

“This Ain’t No Party, This Ain’t No Disco, This Ain’t No Foolin’ Around”

Unfortunately, Chicago is not a party bus. It’s more like an aircraft carrier which has a large crew and is very hard to turn around. And there are a number of different factions among that crew.

One was the long-time staff left over from the patronage systems run by both the elder and junior Mayor Daleys, but the folks left over from that era guard the knowledge of where the light switches are. So you can either work with them or sit in the dark. 

There were a lot of out-of-touch fake progressives left over from the the Lightfoot administration who refused to get on board with being accountable to the people of Chicago.

On top of all of this, Johnson had to onboard the multitudes he brought with him, sometimes having to make grim decisions about who gets off the dock or even out of the water.

An old machine faction of the Chicago city council attempted to put together the votes to override Johnson’s ability to pick committee chairs before he even took command. And that incident may have forced him to cut a deal with and offer political concessions and other goodies to some of the more transactional alderpersons.

I’m not here to make excuses, but the Brandon Johnson and Zohran Mamdani administrations have little to do with the private individuals Brandon Johnson or Zohran Mamdani. Brandon and I both came out of the radical end of the labor movement, and if you’ve been in that scene more than five minutes, you’ve heard the phrase “don’t third-party the union.” That means the members are the union, and the members are solely responsible for the health and performance of the union. To use another metaphor, when I worked as a union rep, I described myself, the elected leaders, other union staff, and the office as a lawnmower. If I leave my lawnmower out in the rain and it gets rusty so my grass gets high, it’s not the lawnmower’s fault. Even if I can sharpen up my blades, fix my engine, and start mowing, it’s going to be rough to mow tall grass. But if I can get the grass down to a reasonable level, it’s going to be a lot easier to maintain.

Another way to say this is that the Johnson administration is the product of a movement that further broke the Chicago Machine. And as the old saying goes, “you break it, you buy it.” So where do we go from here? Do we try to fix the Machine? Do we break it more and attempt to dismantle it altogether? Do we drive it around with the bumper hanging off until we get somewhere? Do we trade up for a newer one? 

Brandon Johnson himself has very little input into this decision. Actually, no individual makes these decisions. The power in a coalition comes from the participation of its constituent groups. The leaders are the leaders exclusively because they have followers. It’s up to movement to inspire its participants to make good use of the progress we have forged. 

My central message is that we are not done after we have played our role in an election. There is more to do. Chicago activists have thrown around the word “co-governance” as a utopian idea of how much we can collaborate with an office that is not set up for our values, no matter who occupies it. One movement leader, shortly before going to work for the Johnson administration, said it best. “We have not achieved co-governance,” they said; “we have changed the conditions under which we are organizing.”

The Wealth of Swamps

“Chicago” is an indigenous word that roughly translates as “stinky onion” – the garlic weed swamp. I’ve always imagined French explorers arriving on the banks of the Des Plaines River in Joliet (a block from my old apartment) and indigenous people selling them on the idea of leaving them alone for now to continue onto “the chicago,” just like a realtor today might try to rebrand a troubled neighborhood they’re attempting to gentrify. 

However, Chicago was not just a swamp, but a swampy portage path. At the dawn of history, in the early days of boating, if you wanted to travel the continent by water, an important step was to get from Lake Michigan to the Des Plaines River. The Chicago wetlands provided you the chance to do that, depending on the water levels, by paddling part of the way rather than carrying your boat. Archer Avenue in particular, but also Route 66, Ogden Avenue, and the I-55, are the legacy of the swamp path. It’s one of the world’s great primal roads. This pathway led to the canal and a port. That caused the original train lines to link here. The trains and waterways brought the roads and freeways. The cowboys brought the livestock from the Great Plains so it could be processed in Sandburg’s “hog butcher for the world.” 

And so all the real wealth comes through Chicago. While New York and Boston have a lot of money, you can’t eat money, except by owning a lot of land, debt, and commerce elsewhere. Why should we let these pieces of paper control our lives? California and Florida have produce, but that rots if you can’t move it in time. 

So how do we access the wealth that flows through Chicago? Who has it now and how do we get hold of it for the people’s needs?

The Room with Some People  

A mayoral election is one small battle in the much longer conflict between those who live in the region and those who own the region. I was at one of many Brandon Johnson victory parties that the Mayor-elect did not attend. The director of the community-based 501(c4) organization hosting the party was nervously texting Brandon’s entourage. “He’s in a room with some people,” the director said. 

I perked up my ears. I’ve heard Chicago community leaders lay out the myth of a ‘smoke-filled room’ like this. The people who own Chicago, it’s theorized, take the mayor in the room and say ‘We don’t work for you. You work for us.’ These capitalists then say what they want from the mayor and the city, and what they can do to the mayor and the city if they don’t get it. Debt can be made due immediately. Industries can be shut down. This is what we call a capital strike: capitalists deliberately shutting down vital infrastructure or tanking the economy to sabotage a left-wing leader or thwart reform.

Several South Side Walmarts were closed down between the election and the swearing-in ceremony. The struggle over government actions and subsidies that helped build these stores had been one of the great struggles (and defeats) of the Chicago social justice movement during the Richard M. Daley administration. Walmart claimed the stores were losing money even though the stores were always full, and the company refused demands to show us the numbers. Many of us saw this as nothing short of a capital strike against the mayor-elect.

First We Get the Money

The people in the back room intentionally obscure themselves from us, but we must track them down and reclaim our wealth. Almost all of our demands cost money.  The budget address is way too late to think about how we’re going to pay for the changes we want. The day after the city budget is done, we need to start a campaign for revenue in the next one. 

Ready or Not, Here We Come

“We should not be on the fifth floor, and I’m speaking my whole heart…we were not ready, because we haven’t been in government long enough to know how government really runs.” 

(Alderwoman Jeanette Taylor, December 2023)

When one is union staff or leadership,  it is tricky to encounter a worksite leader who has bad feelings about the union. Often these feelings are a mix of legitimate grievances and unrealistic expectations. When I was union staff, I would always volunteer to go to sites that were accused of being mad at the union. I can work with any type of anger, but it’s hard to move workers who have fully checked out. 

I tell such leaders the story of the Caucus of Rank & File Educators (CORE), which is a political faction inside Chicago Teachers Union Local 1 (CTU). When I first met Brandon Johnson in 2013, he was chair of the black caucus of CORE. 

The sad truth is that most union members in the U.S. do not vote in union elections and likely struggle to remember the name of their union, let alone have any understanding of its structure. Many members, I tell the frustrated stewards, get mad about this issue or another, find some untapped votes and, boom, they’re in office. You could do that, I tell them. But the problem is that the failings of union officers are not always personal failings. The pressures of the office can crack even the most dedicated organizers. Many elected union leaders are not prepared for the pressures of what they’re going to face, and they become much like the leaders they ran against.

CORE, however, did not seek control of the union until they had power and knew how to wield it. They spent years connecting to their profession and what the school means – not just to teachers, but to the entire community and the public good. They recruited the late Karen Lewis, one of the most authentic and effective leaders in Chicago history, even if she didn’t come from exactly the same political background or traditions as some of the caucus’s founders. CTU won the 2013 strike because Rahm Emmanuel could not split asunder what years of careful thought, exploration, and intense relationship building with the community had wrought. 

But Alderwoman Taylor, one of the Chicago city council’s most prophetic voices, was right. We were not prepared for a progressive mayor. We did not have the luxury of time and preparation. We took a shot from the other side of the court and were amazed by the swish, and we thought that finally, after lifetimes of heartbreak, we might manifest all our wishes. 

Perhaps Alderwoman Taylor is right about one other thing too: Perhaps this was not the type of power we needed to build. In the 1980s, the late Harold Washington was Chicago’s most progressive and first black mayor. Washington’s first term was frustrated at every turn by a racist white voting bloc called the “Vrodolyak 29” during a period referred to as “the Council Wars.” During this period, a 29 members of the city council voted down everything Washington proposed.  Perhaps we should have built the “Taylor 29” before we looked for another potential Harold Washington. 

I’ve spent a lot of time with folks I’ve met on the South Side. They don’t talk much about whether Epstein was murdered, but they will talk your ear off about all the ways they know Harold was.

But what do we do with this revelation from Alderwoman Taylor? Yes, it’s better to build a plane on the ground before you’re in the air. We didn’t have the luxury of years of preparation, so here we are. We need to find the energy to build multiple vehicles of power at the same time.

Chicago Reader columnist Ben Joravsky, the dean of Chicago movement journalism, regularly points out that Chicago doesn’t like nice mayors. He lays out how often we’ve rewarded the bad behavior of our past mayors with defense and support.

We also complain about our mayors being too controlling, but we don’t seem to know how to act when someone shares control and responsibility with others. During the 2024 process to pass the city budget, both supporters and detractors would comment that Johnson had weakened the office of the mayor by “losing control” of the budget process. My response to this commentary was always, “Isn’t that what folks elected him for?” My sense was that he laid the worst-case-scenario budget on the table, and then he made the city council own their own efforts at improving it. I thought that was a genius move. If we’re all invited to the 5th floor, doesn’t that indicate shared responsibility?

“Johnson has fiercely defended his handling of the negotiations over the city’s 2025 spending plan, repeatedly referring to himself as the ‘collaborator in chief’ and disputing suggestions that City Hall has been engulfed in chaos, even as he called on members of the city council to ‘grow up’ and stop throwing tantrums…not only did Johnson’s original budget proposal ask alderpeople to put their political futures at risk by voting for the largest property tax hike since 2016 and the second-largest in Chicago history, but it offered nearly nothing in return for city council members to point to when speaking to angry Chicagoans.”

(WTTW: “Chicago City Council Narrowly OKs Johnson’s $17.1B Budget That Hikes Taxes by $165M”, Heather Cherone, December 16, 2024)

Experience Newark at O’Hare

We are electing nice guys who want to be accessible to everyone, but that’s the same thing as being accessible to no one. There is too much noise and not enough signal in this approach. It causes a lack of transparency – or, at least, there’s no transparency about who is getting the access that matters. It’s nice to get attention, but it’s more vital to know early on about what logistics facility, quantum computing campus, stadium, etc., might get built on top of your neighborhood. A picture with the mayor is nowhere near as exciting as having a point person that you know will bring your issues to the mayor. There needs to be an organized way to get ideas, concerns, and information to not just the mayor but the administration. 

In the documentary Punch 9 for Harold Washington, there’s a scene where folks tell the story of how many ‘no-show’ city jobs they found after Harold was sworn in – corrupt arrangements in which city officials gave jobs to supporters and friends that didn’t require them to do meaningful work. So there’s a real reason to make sure people are at City Hall performing their jobs. But we also need to make sure that the real jobs are sustainable. My friends who work at City Hall look so dead inside. We need to get them fresh air, but we also need to maintain a consistent presence in all neighborhoods throughout the city. If too much governing is happening in one building and not in the neighborhoods, it will never be satisfying.

There are so many coalitions pursuing so many separate campaigns, and they’re all trying to get through the city council as quickly as possible. Progressive alders take meeting after meeting with different groups wanting them to champion similar but different causes, with no clear mandate about what to tackle first. The movement needs to pick what will have the biggest impact and has the most organized people behind it.

But the administration also needs to communicate on their end. If a community leader has spent their lives developing civic infrastructure in their neighborhood, I should not be the one telling them substantial news about their neighborhood; neither should they first hear about it from the media. In fact, they should know about what’s coming, because they should be involved in shaping it. There needs to be a legion of staff who are constantly listening to and engaging the ‘grasstops,’ who, through the moral authority of their hard work, run the civic life of the city. By ‘grasstops’ I mean the block captains, civic associations, campaign volunteers, church deacons, etc. – everyone that is putting in the effort to make the community life of Chicago happen. We can’t knock on every door, but every neighborhood has people that almost every household engages with. 

Not Here for Friendship

Some social justice activists want to elect mayors and support them by never criticizing them publicly and waiting on them for direction. Some on the left want to constantly form a black-and-white assessment of a leader and either blindly follow or viciously attack them. The situation is much more complex than that. 

For any of these officials to have successful administrations, the coalitions that elected them need to temper these tendencies. Movements need to independently continue to make their demands. But also, we need to have a reasonable understanding of and strategy around the real limits of the office and the tough decisions that need to be made. We should not be afraid to be far ahead of the mayor but we should not consume our own tail by having unrealistic expectations of the office. 

We do not live in a world of what is right and just. We live in a world of what is possible with the power we have built. We also do not need to burden the mayor with making decisions that we should be making, and we should not hesitate to be aggressively useful to the administration. We should not hesitate to make moves that perhaps the mayor cannot make as easily.

I know one organizer who jumped into being aggressively useful as soon as the election was over. If they knew something, they said something. If someone was angry at the Mayor, they helped his office know about and understand it. Pretty soon, calling them was on the to-do list of new staff. The administration has a lot to pay attention to, and both the organizer and the administration would have both been weakened if they had waited to be asked.

Everybody Everybody Sent

“Is a tractor bad? Is the power that turns the long furrows wrong? If this tractor were ours it would be good – not mine, but ours.” 

(John Steinbeck, The Grapes of Wrath)

After the election, a number of voices disparagingly and increasingly referred to the CTU and  IFT/AFT Local 1 as “the New Machine.”  The old Chicago political machine was the transactional and tightly controlled system in which a small number of people exchanged their political support for city jobs and other perks. Our trauma from living under the old machine can easily make us cynical about any machine or system of organization.

Ultimately, whatever your politics, that type of machine is stronger than people who do the minimum amount for the maximum benefit and who are too afraid of the boss to act independently. Hopefully, we will put more into building an open, transformational machine that delivers for the region’s people by making deep structural changes, and less into critiquing individual candidates.

Author